Skip to main content
Loading video...

Ask the Chairman - Board Game Q&A 6

Transcript 23:12

hey everybody and welcome to another episode of ask the chairman so this is a board game related Q&A session where you can ask me anything related to board gaming as usual thank you to everybody who submitted questions on the last Q&A and if you want to keep the series going please be sure to leave your questions for future episodes in the comments of this video and I'll be sure to answer them next time now before I get into the questions I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor Kender UK who are my go-to online retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order but let's get cracking on with the questions and the first one comes from Dany and he asks where does my viewer base mainly come from and fortunately YouTube does a great um has a great option to check where your viewers are coming from and um not surprisingly my biggest demographic is from the USA um with nearly 34% of my viewership then it goes down to about 12% from the UK 8% from about Canada and then it goes to Germany and Australia and after that it really is kind of very small uh fraction so yeah generally USA UK and then Canada um just behind that he's also asked have I noticed a difference in Taste of board games based on where my viewers are from unfortunately I don't have any data to um to answer that question so unfortunately I do not know sorry sorry Danny

but thank you for the questions uh next up um Alan 87 has asked which five games would I bring with me to a secluded Island and I could only play them for for the rest of my life now I'm going to assume that these are going to be under perfect circumstances so of course if i' got a part of game um that I love and there's only two players on the island I'm not going to choose that so I'm going to assume that these are all for the perfect player count and the games I've chosen are not far off my favorite games of all time actually so of course I'm going to take El Grande it's my favorite game of all time Chinatown I think would be a really nice one um for that more kind of interactive environment that kind of um negotiation um I've also said trun if for my big brain burner Euro Style game Babylonia and ra so two kinia style games there with lots of replayability and that going to keep me satisfied for a long time but I think all of these games are in my top 10 so again it's not too far off my actual favorite games ever anyway thank you Alan uh Tony has asked how fussy am I about avoiding dents or damaged components now of course I'll do what I can to protect my games and um I prefer them to be in perfect condition but I'm not too fussy about it you know I understand that things get bashed around um you know I'd rather play and enjoy the games than keep them in pristine uh condition and even when I have had a bit of wear and tear on my games that's not really hurt the value of them too much when I come to selling them on the other end so yeah

I'm not too precious about it but I'm not Reckless either of course he's also asked how many games in my collection are permanent Keepers that I will never Cur now I think maybe the ones that have stood the test of time until now I don't really see myself getting rid of games like Al Grande like I mentioned Tren you know all my favorites that I've had on my collection for a long time um but sometimes if there is a new version or slightly tweaked version of the game I might I might be inclined to replace it with the newer one um but all in all there's quite a good proportion of my games that um that I would not sell under any circumstances really um so I'd say probably about half if um just to give an estimate there um he's also asked when games are similar How likely is it that I'll call one of them so it's actually highly likely even if it doesn't happen immediately if I've got two games that are similar I might kind of put them both through the ropes really give them both several plays until I finally decide which one I'm going to keep out of the two now recently I played um a couple of fantastic TI placement games or or decent ones wild TI West and um world wonders now I really like both of the games they're both quite similar um I could keep both but I thought what's the point I'm just going to dilute my plays of them was I'd rather just keep my one that's know slightly favorable than the other one so I ended up keeping wild t West but yeah sometimes even if I'm inspired by a game and it's similar

to one I have in my collection and I might think I'll keep hold of both of these eventually one of them is going to kind of fall off the bottom if that makes sense but thank you for your questions Tony Mr Joo has asked will I be doing an updated collection rundown um anytime soon yes I certainly will be um I'll be recording that probably in the next couple of weeks um I did it last time in March of 2023 so I thought I'd make it an annual thing and do it in March of 2024 this time so um that video should be out relatively soon so keep your eyes peeled uh for that one um RB Ruba has asked which five games from my top 100 do I excel in uh really good question um I think all of these games are my are in my top 100 um Patchwork might be slightly below it but patw is a game I'm generally quite good at I've played it dozens of times my score is generally pretty decent um mandala I've got a very good winning percentage record of same with Hannah mcoi um because I did play it so much the games that I kind of figured out the nuances and intricacies of uh wits and wages is something completely different you know a party kind of a guesstimation Style game and my my my winning percentage of that game is very high I'm generally pretty good at general knowledge um as well as El Grande you know another mention for El Grande um generally funny enough the games that are my absolute favorites are normally games I'm not very good at because I

have that desire to come back and get better than them better at them El Grande I do win quite a lot and it still maintains to be one of my favorite games so it's just that good of a design but in contrast to that question um he's asked which five games are the weakest in um in my kind of top 100 again I think some of these might be just below that but um Rumble Nation I've got a horrible record of but it's one of my favorite games I'm not even sure if I've ever won a game of Rumble Nation bonfire Stephan Feld game that I every time I play the game I always try to do too much and every time I fail um so hopefully that will change soon enough photograph is a game that I find very difficult to excel in I'm I'm not good at the the game at all and I always feel like I'm kind of um treading water in that one Amsterdam another Stephen Feld game one that I'm really bad at this is a game you have to plan several turns ahead and get cards made I always struggle and end up going for the cheap cheap and cheerful options rather than building towards anything substantial uh Terror mystica I'm not very good at at all and also miies is a game that I'm not good at at all I find them all very difficult to Gro and um you know I'm not terribly experienced with a lot of these um but still a lot of the time because I'm so experienced with Euros I I kind of it's a bit like a duct to water really it becomes easy for me or at least I can find my feet and these ones I struggle every single time but thank you for the questions really interesting ones there uh Keith has asked Which

percentage or what percentage of my collection are rated 3.5 or higher in terms of complexity and that's actually quite a low figure probably lower than you'd expect maybe about 5% um you know looking over my shoulder there aren't actually that many games of that weight bracket you know I've got Darwin's Journey I've got a barrage teram maraio Kus and maybe a couple of the fail games like bonfire um and stuff like that but other other than that most of them are below that 3.5 waiting and um yeah so it's actually quite a low figure um as you than you probably um expect to uh or expected me to say but thank you for the question um Keith uh moving on then to Mike um he's asked what games would I like to see made into a roll and WR or card version to make it easier to hit uh the table now I only thought of a couple of these and I thought teram mystica might be a good idea I could see that working in a in a roll and right Style game um you're just ticking off buildings as you put them on the map I can see that working you know unlocking more income I don't see why that wouldn't work um also um a game that I thought of was that a game I really enjoyed actually but one that I knew I wouldn't play very much is Crystal Palace now Crystal Palace had an amazing mechanism where you would roll dice and that would be the strength of

your workers but if you wanted to use them that would be the cost that you have to pay money in order to activate that worker placement spot a really big brain burner but I could see that mechanism being condensed down into like a little roll and right game with you know just a p of paper and a few dice I could really see that working so Crystal Palace just a little kind of um out of the left field um suggestion there he's also asked what are what are my favorite three board game components I didn't think too much into this but ones that immediately sprang to mind were uh any kind of cube tower now I love Cube Towers in games like wallenstein Marakesh Amero just a great feature and very few board games feature a cube Tower um in terms of kind of tactility I like the the temples in Mexico the newest version of Mexico by super Meo they are really nice and components for good value and a little contraption that I really liked was the um the guessing wheel from a game called wavelength the kind of party game where you would kind of suggest on this wavelength where you thought the answer would be and it all worked very nicely it was high quality and it did the job so I I kind of like components that are you know they do job they do the job they do what they're supposed to and they're of high quality um another kind of suggestion I would say is something like the iron Clays um of course they were initially assigned to the Brass Birmingham reprint but I use them in any single game that I can really because I like them that much but thank you for

the questions um and Matt has asked how do we get you back into reviewing more heavy uh Euros um it's not a deliberate side step I've done from the heavier Euros just nothing has really grabbed my attention in this last year or so um nucleum is one that I probably will try uh and I know a lot of you guys wanted me to try games like um I forgot it's called I can't remember what it's called now the um I forget what it's called one of the Euros um kind of a Medieval theme I'll put the um I'll put the caption below but uh that was one that I was semi-in interested in trying but I decided not to because it just didn't seem to have enough going on and all the other kind of Euros I seem to be like Garfield games which I'm not really interested in and stuff like that so if something's going to come along and my attention then I'll certainly try it but right now the heavier Euros just aren't really um grabbing me to be honest but um it's certainly not a deliberate um kind of change of my content I suppose Joe has asked um what is my favorite tea game my favorite te game at the moment and it's by a very small margin is tetum it's currently my top 20 and just a couple of steps above um zul in the mine calendar so those two are my favorite at the moment it was Tris majest more recently my tastes have changed a bit lighter because trist majest is very heavy um and that one's Fallen a bit below but yeah currently the Two Front Runners are tetum and then

zulin then I'd probably go to something like TR mesus tan and stuff like that he's also asked funny enough what is my favorite gari game uh my favorite gari game is Hadrian's Wall kind of grandiose roll and right Style game but even then I was lukew one it I thought it's a good game one that I wasn't really too um too bothered about returning to I thought I'd seen everything pretty quickly um all the other stuff like the West Kingdom games um the you know the North Sea games all those games don't appeal to me at all I played them they're all average at Best in my opinion um CH has asked what themes would you like to see more of uh in board games and this is going to be a pretty boring answer um because I love medieval themed games I love Renaissance style games all those traditional Euro trading the medit Mediterranean which you know a few years ago they were coming out a lot but nowadays you don't see them too often so actually I think they're going to have a Resurgence sooner rather than later because it seems like every game now is like a nature themed game or something like that which for me doesn't do much for me if I'm honest and but in terms of intellectual properties I'd love to see more kind of house of the dragon games or um you know any kind of Game of Thrones or Song of Ice and Fire themes because it's such a cool IP where you can add so many different types of games area control games kind of political Intrigue style games um and me being such a fan of the you know those books I would love to see more themes but that's more kind of a selfish perspective but

thank you for the question uh nerdington has asked uh why do I hate SCI sci-fi themes uh so much um it's not like I hate them I don't hate them they just again they leave me feeling very numb and cold um I just don't have any dra draw or appeal to them or they don't appeal to me at all there are the odd exception you know I've got Pulsar 2849 in the collection um but I like that purely because of the mechanisms and not because of the Space theme other than that I don't think I have any space theme games uh at all I don't know I just always been I've always been a fantasy fan um I always lik Lord of the Rings I've always liked again Game of Thrones um I like Stormlight Archive books you Brandon serson books that's my thing I've always liked it sci-fi I've never got into I've never really found an IP that matches my you know personality or tastes so hence why I've always leaned towards SciFi more than sorry lean towards fantasy more than sci-fi he's also asked does that transfer over to TV and and films or movies uh yes it does again for the same reason I've never really seen anything sci-fi that appeals to me too much um so yeah even even Star Wars doesn't really do much for me um he's asked um what does replayability uh mean to me very simple in my perspective it's just that appeal to return to the game to play it some more um I guess what you're suggesting with this question is does it just mean more content no it doesn't I

think that's a pitfall that a lot of people fall into sometimes you can get um modules and stuff for games that people would assume is replayability I don't think that now don't get me wrong it can be that um but for me some of the most replayable games are games that are always the same games like Babylonia games like raw you're never chopping and changing me modules or adding new cards in they're always the same but for me the desire to come back to them is so high because it has that depth to complex complexity ratio and those tactical decisions mixed with the um strategic decisions and always getting kind of reacting on the Fly and reacting to the board State that's what I like um games that come make you come back that way rather than just throwing more material um at you so yeah simply just the appeal to return to the game uh stock Trader boy has asked uh how often do I play games so I normally have um two game evenings um per week with my friends and normally with my family I'll have like a gaming day as well so on my day of work I will um I'll go visit my family we'll play some games during the day so yeah normally two evenings and a day as well um and off sometimes off the on occasion if um if I have some spare time me and my girlfriend might play a few games together and um you know get some more games played uh that way too and that kind of leads into the next question he asked do I actually work yes I do you know I know I play a lot of games but this is my main hobby um and I uh I do work a lot as well um so I like

to enjoy my time off and I don't even spend all my time playing ball games you know I do have other Hobbies as well you know I like visiting places um you know I train at the gym um I read a lot um I like films um so yeah I'm I'm quite a busy man and that's the way I like it to be uh and he's asked how do I find other players uh to play these games often um all my best friends play board games so that's great um my girlfriend started playing board games um my family all play board games as well at least my brother does and um also my mom's quite heavily involved in board gaming as well now because I've played so many games with her she's got a really good um knowledge and diverse tasting games now so we can play almost anything together and we always to have a good time so yeah very fortunate I understand that a lot of people rely on local gaming groups and stuff I I'm not in that position even though there is a great local gaming group um I often do play with my close friends um and family who I knew before even getting into ball games you know people that met through Sports and other stuff like that so um yeah that's who I play most of my board games um with so on to another few questions now these are from till from the previous episode cuz he asked so many questions I said I'd return to them and answer the rest of them on this episode so till um hopefully um well thank you for your patience for me to answer these ones um he's asked me what um what is the most interesting pure tile laying game or games um looking at my collection I think there's one

definitive Tire placement game that is Head and Shoulders Above the Rest and that is Glenn Mo 2 Chronicles you say pure I'm not sure what you mean by that but that for me is the main focus of the game yes there is a Time Track system but for me it's all about the toll laying also Acropolis is one that I've really fallen for in these last couple of years so yeah Acropolis and Glen Mo 2 Chronicles for me he's asked um what does balanced mean uh to me so for me when you're talking about a balanced board game I want to go into the board game knowing that I have a fair shot of winning the game I'm not going into it with a a ball and chain around my ankles and I'm going to be fighting an uphill battle that for me is a hug huge turnoff I understand that it's not all games could be perfectly balanced if they are they're probably going to be some kind of abstract strategy game um but yeah I want to have you know everybody to have a fair shot uh at winning he's asked are you aware of a game called jeru yes I am I've not played it um I might pick it up one day in the future I'm not sure he's asked what are my thoughts on race for the Galaxy certainly a very influential game one that has still played a lot to this get day I have played it a few times I liked it I didn't love it I thought it was a little bit clunky I thought the um again maybe an easy thing to go to the symbology and the layout and the kind of um you know graphic design of the Cs wasn't ideal I thought that was a bit laborious at times for me but I can

certainly see why people enjoy it it's a well-designed game a well polished game um but one for me maybe going back to that sci-fi thing one that didn't quite land 100% but again I completely see why people would like um race for the Galaxy for me it was about six out of 10 he's asked what are my thoughts on combo tastic games um I love them these are the kind of games that I do lean towards whether they' be big or small know a lot of my favorite big games games like um Tran have a lot of combos praga kaput Reni has combos a game like rise has combos they're some of my favorite games in terms of smaller games like you know Gans Shan clever I love that idea of just kicking one thing off that let you do another another another and that kind of chain reaction yeah big fan of that style of um of gameplay it asked me what are my thoughts on Michael shot games um I've only ever ever played a couple of them I've played coloretto Zulo and hanza as well um all of which I think are good I think coloretto was excellent um hanza very old school style Euro um I liked it um I thought it had limited shelf life um and and zolto I thought was kind of surplus to requirements because coloretto exists and the other games I haven't tried so I can't really comment but um I'd certainly be up for giving them a go he's asked me when does a game stop being a filler game uh for me generally speaking not I'm not strict on it but you want to be setting up the

game teaching the game um playing the game and packing up the game in around 30 minutes or or less of course um but again I'm not too strict if it goes to 35 I might still consider it a filler game um and I think the final question of the episode is again from till he's asked is in the year of the dragon an underrated uh board game um if you're not aware of what in the year of the dragon is it's a stanfeld game that's probably one of his most polarizing because it's known for being so brutal and so punishing um I love it it's one of my favorite Fel games for me I write I rate it at 8 and a half out of 10 which is way above the average rating on on board game Geeks so in that respect I do think it's underrated um at least from my P my perspective but is it underrated in the grand scheme of things I understand and can objectively see this is a niche design it's not going to be for everybody and it's still ranked at 418 um on the board game Beek rankings so I think that's pretty fair if not pretty good um for a game of that type because I think just as many people are going to bounce off this game and even actively hate it as they are going to love it so I think 418 is um a really respectable score and in that respect I wouldn't say it was underrated but no I personally think it's fantastic in my top 20 or 30 games I think it's that good um but that's it thank you for the questions everybody I really do uh appreciate it as always please be sure to answer or to ask more

questions uh in the comments of this video otherwise I will have to stop the series um and of course I need you guys feedback to keep it going but if you have enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like And subscribe to the channel and check out my other content too and for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye

Progress saved