RANKING 50 Board Games with amazing table presence!
Transcript
hi i'm adam porter i recently made a video about table presence in board game design and this was inspired by my own experiences of creating the game picoco which i think was a game that had great table presence but in my recent video i didn't pass judgment on any of the games that i mentioned i didn't say whether i liked them or not and that was mentioned in the comments on that video that people would have liked to know but are these games any fun so that's what i'm going to try and do in this video is go through 50 different games and talk about whether i personally found them fun or not and i'm going to be ranking them according to that so you can take it as a given that these games have amazing table presents by which i mean people are going to glance across the room and go what is that person playing and i want to play all these games fulfill that criteria but i'm going to be ranking them according to how fun they are for me which means there are going to be some in there which i know are extremely popular games that i personally don't really like and there are going to be others which really aren't popular games that nobody really seems to know about but i particularly enjoy so this is by no means an authoritative list it's my personal taste and there's a couple of rules that i'm going to put on here so one is i'm not including any games just purely on the basis of artwork alone so there'll be no dixit no takaido no oceans these games with amazing artwork and graphic design they don't fulfill my central criteria of having one physical component three-dimensional component that really stands out and the other rule is i'm not allowing games onto the list purely on the basis
of miniatures with a couple of minor exceptions and and i think you'll understand why the exceptions are there i hope uh maybe i'm being a little bit loose with that rule but there are so many games out there with fantastic miniatures that that could make a whole list in itself and also i don't play that many heavy sort of miniatures games so let's kick off with the game manhattan which is an old spieled as yares winner it's had a more recent edition by fox mind but it's not a game that gets talked about hugely although really it is on a level of things like ticket to ride in terms of accessibility and it can be a little bit mean okay it's an area control game so you can get in each other's way and it can lead to a little bit of bad feeling maybe that's why it's not quite so renowned as as ticket to ride and others from that spieled as yara's sort of stable but manhattan yeah you're building these skyscrapers with these plastic pieces in the most recent edition from fox mind they are very colorful translucent pieces which means it all looks very tropical and not particularly like new york city um but nonetheless i still prefer that version to what we had before it looks beautiful it looks like a load of sweets on the board and it's a really fun game i'm calling this one a tier okay really good good game right number two on my list then these are in no particular order this one is takanoko so in this one we're building out a garden and we've got a little panda and a little gardener no one owns those pieces but all players can control both of them and you're trying to fulfill objectives that you have on cards in your hand a bit like in ticket to ride so you might be trying to get the panda to eat
certain colors of bamboo or trying to get the gardener to grow different levels of different colors of bamboo it's really fun it's simple but it's probably family weight plus yeah you probably want to have a few other board games under your belt before you start playing takanoko really satisfying and very very beautiful on the table so next on the list is pylos pylos is a old um wooden game from uh gigamic it's from their modern classics range so you've got these little wooden balls and you're stacking them up to create a pyramid very sort of strategic thinky sort of game uh takes a lot of brainpower to work out what you're gonna do i haven't quite got my head totally around it and it's not my favorite from the range of games here although it is one of the most beautiful in that range so pylos i'm calling that one a bead here b tier for pylos number four on the list is junk art so junk art is a stacking game you've got all sorts of different wooden shapes of different um different you know different pieces all shaped differently all different colors and you're stacking them up the rules keep changing throughout the game so you've got um not throughout the game but different rounds of the game you have different rule sets to play with these blocks essentially you're playing with building blocks and just hoping that the other players towers fall before yours do which is always really really satisfying it's one of my favorite mechanisms in the game is stacking pieces so junk art comes in this lovely big wooden box which really adds to the appeal and it's one of those games where people are always going to be getting out their camera and taking photographs of what they've built you know stacking games
have table presents like nothing else so junk art really good game lots of variety in that box i'm calling it a tier okay next on the list then is flick em up which is from the same publisher as junk art and like junk art flickermp comes in two versions you can have the plastic version which is smaller and cheaper or you can have the big wooden version i've got the big wooden version and you can basically build this wild west sort of playground on your on your tabletop um with the expansions you can bring in native americans and and and they're shooting arrows and horses riding on horses and you're going in and out of the bank robbing the bank or going in the you know the sheriff's building or you know it's it's a fantastic really thematic game with lots and lots of scenarios you can try all sorts of different things out with flick them up um a bit bulky you know there's there's a lot going on and it can be a bit intimidating once you've got all that stuff you know i always think i've got to set all this up and then remember all the rules for all the different pieces but nonetheless fantastic game flick them up i'm calling it a tier okay next on the list number six this is one that i don't own and it's cthulhu wars and this is one of the ones that i said was an exception because this is on here because of the miniatures and the reason i'm making the exception for it is because these miniatures are not miniature okay they're huge and they're everywhere the table is just full of these massive monsters these cthulhu monsters now cthulhu is not really a theme that connects with me i've never found it particularly interesting i've never read any of it i've played a few of the games and not generally enjoyed
them very much cthulhu wars i wouldn't normally play but i played it at a convention with lots of strangers and i actually had a really nice time playing i really enjoyed it um it was big it was complicated i don't really want to play it again but nonetheless it impressed me enough that i managed to get through the game enjoy it engage with it when i really wasn't expecting to but it does look amazing cthulhu was with those massive weird toys essentially that are all laid out on the table so i'm calling this one a b tier okay beat here for cthulhu wars number seven is bunny kingdom and this is going to be our first s-tier game okay i love bunny kingdom it's one of my favorite games of all time so here it's a pick and pass card game where you take a card you pass the others on the cards that you take have grid references and you're placing bunnies out onto the board trying to occupy the castles in order to score points and build up areas you know little thiefs they're called but little little communities of bunnies little kingdoms fantastic game bunny kingdom and it just looks so cute those plastic pieces are amazing number eight on the list is river dragons now river dragons was very very popular uh i don't know probably about 10 years ago there was a you could buy a giant version of it a bit like you could with takanoko a big wooden box full of it very very beautiful laying out um sort of bridges between stones so that your pieces can move across this river but it's a programming game so you lay out your plans before you start taking your turn and then other players are
going to mess up those turns with their plans their program that they've laid out i don't like that sort of game i find that one of the most frustrating game mechanisms i've talked about this before so river dragons didn't work for me i played it a number of times and it was really popular people really loved it and so you know i'm obviously the exception there but not for me for me river dragons is a d-tier game even though it's beautiful number nine on the list gazanka after planka which i've talked about recently in a review this is a zok verlag game soccer verlag is one of my favorite publishers this one has a sort of rocking pirate ship and you're moving the pirates around to try and get the planks to tip over and knock your opponents out into the sea um it's a decent little family game uh the rule set isn't isn't perfect i don't think it's not one of zok's best but it's by no means a bad game i would call this one a well i'm going to call it a c tier but it's a high c it's a no pun intended um okay right number 10 tobago okay tobago is another zok verlag game and this is one of their best okay it's one of their most popular it's stuck around for years and years it's you could argue that i'm putting this on here because of miniatures but these aren't miniatures in the form of little sculptures they're little palm trees and and statues and little wooden cars that drive around this island and you're looking for treasure you're playing out cards which say the treasure is within a couple of spaces of a tree or it's it's not within two spaces of the the ocean
or it's contained within the forest you know and and so you're gradually whittling down where that treasure can be and racing to get there before the other players it's a really fun game and very very beautiful when it's laid out on the table so that one i'm calling um a tier for tobago right medina number 11 medina i just love the cityscape that you create in medina i think games have been trying to do this so much you know lots of games have tried to do it to create a sort of three-dimensional cityscape on the table i think medina does it better than almost any other game so you've got these different wooden shapes that represent the different buildings you lay them out you're trying to score different sets and and lay out your sort of citizens of this city and it's been a while since i've played it so i can't get into the mechanisms too much more detail than that but it's really fun and it's very very beautiful um so medina i'm calling an a-tier game okay next up on the list is evidel and this is another s tier okay i love evidel yes the artwork is a huge part of it the artwork is very very beautiful but it's also got all those lovely resource pieces and then that amazing three-dimensional tree which the cards sit on top of and it's a useless tree it doesn't really serve any real purpose apart from to catch the eye and actually it gets in the way if you're playing with more than say three players but i've not really played it much with the higher player counts i tend to play this as a two player game sometimes at three probably wouldn't go much higher than that so the tree doesn't bother me at all in fact i quite like it so very eye-catching the game everdell
and it's a fantastic worker placement resource management game okay number 13 is quarto so this is another game from the same range the modern classics range the same range as pylos and quarto i think is the best game in that range this is essentially you're connecting up four pieces and you might be connecting four of the same color or four pieces that are all round or four pieces that are all square or maybe four that are solid or four that are hollow or four that are tall or four that are short and no one owns any of these pieces on your turn you play the piece that your opponent chooses for you and just that twist is just amazing it's a really clever really simple game and very very satisfying and it looks so sort of stylish a bit like pilos it's one of those games that you might leave out on a table top a coffee table and it all looks very sophisticated uh and sleek like a it's just a really nice object to own but it's an s-tier game okay it's fantastic quarter really really good quality game number fourteen camel up so camel up i'm going to call a tier okay camel up is another speed as yares winner you can see the spirit of ziarez do tend to like these uh these table presence games with these physical gimmicks i suppose in the in the center of them and i don't say that as a pejorative i love the gimmick in camel up so camel up has this central uh pyramid dice shaker that's unnecessary but you essentially shake it up and then you release dice from this pyramid and you've got the camels that stack on top of each other they're racing around the track and if the
camels move then they take everything that's on top of them with them and you're betting on which cameras are going to win the race it's a really fun almost feels like a party style game really but with lots and lots of pieces on the table so camel up is eightier right number 15 on the list is santorini now santorini is another abstract strategy game like pilos and quarto but it's not like them at all in the way that it looks okay because it's full of plastic and you're creating another cityscape you're creating um santorini in front of you with these white buildings and these blue rooftops and then the miniatures that move about and climb up to the different levels i do like games that play with sort of three-dimensional and different levels in relation to the scoring and this is a good example of that lots of different powers that you can use to change up the gameplay i think this is a good game i bought it i got rid of it i wish i hadn't got rid of it i would still like to own it but it obviously didn't hold my attention all that much so i'm calling this one a b tier okay good solid game santorini right number 16 the climbers and this is another one which is very abstract and has height as part of the well it's the main thing in the game you want to get higher than all the other players but your playing piece can only move on the colors on the blocks uh the surfaces of the blocks that match the color of your piece and so you're rotating the blocks throughout the game moving them to change this kind of i don't know what is it a mountain or a tower and you can use these little ladders to get up higher but you want to get to the top um to a position where the other players can't get any higher
and then you're holding that highest position it's a good abstract game if you're playing with more than two players yeah most abstract games work best for two players this one works better with more um but it's not in the highest rung of those things so i'm calling this one b tier yeah it's a good game the climbers but it's not one of the best right number 17 is colt express and this is another one where it's a really popular game another spelled as yara's winner but it's not one that i liked because of the programming again like river dragons i just don't enjoy that mechanism where i lay out my plans and everybody else can wreck it but colt express caught my eye like no other game i remember being an essential just being amazed by this three-dimensional train laid out on the table and the playing pieces running across the top of the train or inside the middle of the train and they're shooting at each other and trying to grab each other's loot and it's a chaotic um very very eye-catching game but i didn't enjoy it and so for me it's a deed here okay next up then is tokyo highway number 18. so tokyo highway i've got the player version the original italian additional though i think it came out later from asthma day with a much bigger version and this one essentially you're just stacking little discs and ice lolly sticks uh and placing those little cars on them with tweezers it's sort of got a dexterity well a massive dexterity element to it but it's also quite sort of tactical really um i found this one really satisfying and enjoyable uh and i think the way it looks is just stunning it
does create this sort of almost slightly futuristic sort of picture of criss-crossing highways like those really compact cities around the world so stunning table presents from very simple components and actually a really nice gameplay as well i like tokyo highway a lot i'm calling this one a tier right number 19 is origin so origin is another objective based game like takanoko and ticket to ride where you're trying to complete different objectives but main the main um pull for this game is the fact you've got all these brilliant wooden pawns of different colors different thickness different height and as you sort of move from one part of the world to another they kind of evolve and so they might get a little bit thicker or they might just change color slightly or they might get shorter or taller and so the pieces sort of evolve as they move around the board and you're trying to fulfill these objectives of getting different pieces into different places um it is really beautiful the gameplay isn't quite as good it's a little simplistic it's not quite as good as the way the game looks and so ultimately i found this game didn't have the staying power that i wanted from it um but it's by no means a bad game it is fun i'm going to call it i want to call it b but i'm going to go with c it's a c to a game okay it's decent i i don't i think you should give it a go origin um but it's it's it's not the best right number 20 tikal so tikal is a wolfgang kramer michael keisling
game another spirit of yares winner i believe um and this one had an old rio grande edition which i had with nice cardboard pieces and stuff like that but it wasn't beautiful and then super meeple created one of the most beautiful productions i've ever seen with these resin pieces that stack on top of each other to create these temples around this lovely forest it's a fantastic game action points lots of scope for analysis paralysis in this one so pick your players carefully but really good strategic area control type game that's tcal and i'm calling that one um should we go s or should we go a we'll go eight here okay eight here for tikal number 21 is photosynthesis so photosynthesis from blue orange is one of the most inspiring games to me as a game designer okay and yet i don't like the game okay i just love the presentation of it i want to create games that look like photosynthesis so simple so effective um and you know surely we can do more with these three-dimensional pieces without you know without breaking the budget because these are cardboard pieces and yet it looks amazing i found the gameplay to be for me it was a little more convoluted than i like from an abstract game it was quite mean um i was expecting something more simple a bit more that horrible word elegant okay than i got from photosynthesis um but nonetheless extremely popular game just happens for me
that it's a d tier right number 22 rhino hero super battle from harbour this is a game where you're you've got folded cards and you're stacking them on top of each other originally there was rhino hero a small sort of one tower and then you've got super battle where you've got several towers and they're joined by little bridging pieces and then you're placing wooden pieces onto the card so the whole thing starts to sway because it's all very very light um this is a game that's ostensibly aimed at children but actually it's really really fun with a group of adults i absolutely love rhino heroes super battle it's really funny i love the payoff of stacking games when everything just falls apart and somebody just loses because the whole thing's just collapsed in a big pile it's hilarious um this one for me is an a tier okay rhino heroes super battle number 23 pyramid of penguin so this one is from brain games it's a re-release of an old game called um curse of the mummy completely reworked in terms of the art style you've got a magnetic board that sits between the players you've got a team of penguins that work together on one side of the board and then you've got a mummy player who works alone on the other side of the board and the treasure hunter the penguins they're moving their little magnets on their side of the board but they can see where the mummy is because when the mummy moves their little piece the mummy magnet on the other side moves with it almost by magic when the pieces click together when the mummy catches the people that are so dramatic because you're trying to sneak past that mummy but then the mummy catches you it's it's fantastic and it just looks great you know there's this three-dimensional board
and it's a really good game so this one i'm calling at the pyramid of penguin all right number 24 on the list is scythe now scythe is another one of those ones that maybe i'm making an exception here because a lot of the visual appeal of side is about those miniatures but it's not just that it's the epic scope of the board and the resources and the little meeples and those boards with the dual layers and the little dials that you turn and you know the whole thing is just this this big beautiful production and it's not even artwork that would particularly appeal to me usually i didn't i took a long time before i played scythe i i was put off by the mechs where a lot of people were really drawn in by them um but nonetheless it's a fantastic game and it does look beautiful so for me this is an a tier for scythe where does that take us to goblet so goblet is another one of those coffee table style games wooden pieces just looks like a lovely little object the pieces stack over the other pieces so again we're trying to connect four but your pieces get hidden and then you might move a piece and accidentally reveal one of your opponent's pieces it's a really clever twist on the genre really good game probably not quite as good as quarto i'm going to call this one um it's an a tier 8 here b2 no it's a b tier we'll go bt goblet b tier for goblet good game really good game number 26 zolkin the mayan calendar now this one has these big plastic gears it's a quite a complex worker placement style game i don't know whether it quite qualifies as work placement i'd have to get my head around that but anyway it's
an action selection game you place your pieces out you rotate these gears your pieces move your workers move with the gears and then when you remove it you get the resource of the thing that you ended up on now it's been many years since i played this but i did play it a number of times i never picked up a copy which suggests to me i didn't love it but i think also it was partly because i knew a lot of people who owned it and it was a very popular game at the time you don't see it around quite so much these days i'd really like to get hold of a copy of this i think for now i'm going to call it a bead here but i think it could rise if i played it a little bit more number 27 potion explosion so this one has this amazing marble dispenser and it's a a twist on that sort of match three gameplay that you get in mobile phone games you take a marble from the dispenser the other marbles drop down click together uh if they match then you might take more of those and so you get these chain reactions you then place the colored marbles onto your potions and when you complete a potion because you've got the right colored marbles on it it gives you special powers um frankly it it looks better than it is okay the the gameplay is not quite as good as the central mechanism it's a fun game it is fun but it's quite simplistic what's going on um and it feels like there should be a little bit more it feels like that central marble dispenser is your main draw in this game i would recommend it potion explosion it's a b-tier game number 28 shobu so shobu is another abstract strategy game these ones do quite well on table presents and i think that's because you need something you haven't got a theme so your table presence is the thing you're
aiming for to draw players in shobu looks very natural it reminds me of old you know ancient games like um go and and and mankala that can be played with pebbles because that's what you've got in shobu is a bunch of pebbles and these little boards and a bit of rope and you're moving pieces that moves other corresponding pieces on other boards a bit like we see in the recent game that time you killed me and you're trying to push pieces off the board by the movement of your pebbles really good game show boo i'm going to call this one a tier for shobu next up then number 29 celestia this is another one that i once owned played a few times got rid of really like that little cardboard airship in the middle and i should love this game because i love push your luck games it's one of my favorite genres this one just didn't quite work for me um i always felt like i didn't quite know why i was making the decisions i was making like the decision space seemed very small it just seemed like a guess and uh i don't know i'm probably being unfair i never felt like i got my head around that game all that much um certainly other players seemed to really enjoy it and i i liked it but i like the appearance of it more than the gameplay again i'm calling this one c tier okay c tier for celestia number 30 is dimension so this is a game from cosmos where we're stacking little plastic balls of different colors and we're creating a pyramid you lay out six i think it is six cards which give you different rules that uh you need to abide by when you're laying out your your balls um and you're trying to complete that puzzle before the other
player so it's a race against the other players um i really really like this and it was uh part of a big inspiration for the game quasal but there were things in it which i felt like i needed to kind of fix really i don't like the scoring in dimension a lot of negative scoring and then there's that thing where the cards that laid out you know you can't necessarily complete them all but then there's this bonus you're aiming for but you can't get that bonus because you can't complete all the cards so it's not a perfect design from my my personal perspective but i do really really like it and the way it looks is is fantastic so i call this one b tier okay b tier for dimension number 31 kip mia saures so this is a recent zok verlag release i talked about this in my recent video um got these teetering sort of towers you put dice into them they might tip over and spill out the dice and then you're drafting those dice for set collection purposes again it's another one where the the device itself is probably more interesting than the game the game is good okay it's a simple fun game really good for families very few rules um but it's not exceptional okay whereas the device is fantastic it was a bit of a pain to put this one together and putting it back in the box you've got to take it apart a little bit and then put it back together next time which is always a little bit of a pain um so this is sort of mid-range really i would call this one a b tier okay beat here for kit mirzarez next one up is cusco which is a game closely related to the game tcal so by the same designers same publisher um with area control again it used to be
called java this game in its original edition you're building up a sort of landscape i really like that that we're stacking um these hexes on top of each other and we're creating hills and valleys and and like i've mentioned with santorini before you're you're benefiting by getting into the higher levels and i really like that being up on the hill gives you more points than being down in the valleys um looks stunning it's actually my favorite of the mask trilogy so i like this more than tea cow i'm going to call this one let's go est here stir for cusco i really really love it it's been a favorite of mine for a long time number 33 i'm almost scared to say this but i don't really like azul very much okay azul is such a popular game such a massive seller um and it's okay i quite it's okay i don't mind it i'd happily play it it feels to me like a roll them right okay that's what it feels like it feels like it should be rolling right but instead it's got all these beautiful pieces and they are lovely but it's all just a bit big and bulky and i found the the gameplay it's not quite as i don't know i don't i don't even understand why i don't like usual all that much um i've never played any of the sort of other versions of it and maybe that would improve it for me i don't know i like the central sort of drafting i like the pieces um just feels a little insubstantial for me azul so that one is going down as a c tier for azul okay i'm sorry okay next up number 34 cloud city so cloud city is a blue orange game from
phil walker harding i think it's flown under the radar a little bit this is another one of those ones where we're building a cityscape a bit like tokyo highway we're creating these towers and they've got little walkways along them i suppose they're supposed to be skyscrapers coming up above the above the clouds but really it's an abstract game very very simple trying to complete objectives and score points by by having the longest walkways between your towers and it's just got a really great visual sort of appearance once you've once you've finished the game um i really enjoyed it cloud city so i'm going to call that one a b it's a beat here cloud city and next on the list is wingspan and there's not much more to say about this game than i've already said about it before i love the bird box dice tower i love the beautiful little eggs i love the images on the cards everything about it just looks stunning i've got all these upgraded little resource pieces which i know don't come with a basic game but even the basic game as it comes is a really really attractive one and it really helps of course it's a fantastic game it's not as accessible as people make out okay there's millions of people buying this game who i'm sure are quite confused by it because there's some sort of sophisticated gameplay going on here you know it's got a sizeable rule book lots of engine building and tableau building and all that sort of stuff that's familiar to gamers but not necessarily familiar to everybody else but for me this is an estee game number 36 niagara this is a spiel desyara's winner again with a fantastic table presence this one's got the box is has a
river running across the top of it and then a waterfall at the end of the box and the river is represented by these translucent plastic discs and they move you know you push them and so they move all the other translucent discs and sometimes they'll fall off the end representing the water going over the waterfall but your boats sit on top of these plastic discs so when they're the discs are pushed the boats go with them um and it's a really great mechanism i didn't get on with the game all that much i didn't like the end game i found that it dragged on because players would keep on stealing pieces from each other that just kept delaying the ending of the game and so by the end of it i was totally unengaged so i think with some tweaks this could be a game that really really worked for me maybe some house rules i don't know but as it is it's a game that i owned and i got rid of eventually i'm calling this one c tier seed here for niagara okay number 37 agricola i'm sure a lot of people wouldn't agree with me putting agriculture on a game on a list of table presence games but for me it's exactly what i want i want to be building something out in front of me like those cityscapes but in this case i'm building a farm i've got my little animals and my fences and my stables it's just my little thing and i'm just building it building it out very satisfying to create something three-dimensionally in front of me and i have got upgraded pieces but i believe the more recent editions of agriculture have upgraded pieces in them anyway i think it looks stunning and it's a fantastic game at the center of it absolutely brilliant strategic game quite complex game if you haven't played it before um worker
placement and for me it's an stf okay absolutely top run game this one right number 38 strand unter another game from zok verlag you'll see the soccer like excel in games with table presents this one you've got a beach and you've got the the sea is gradually coming out initially and it's revealing shells and you want to gather these shells of different colours to build sand castles you put the sand castles onto the beach and you score more points if they're close to the sea but the trouble is the closer you get to the sea the more likely they are to be washed away when the sea starts to come back in towards the end of the game so there's a really nice push your luck element to it um it's it's a satisfying fun game this one uh i i really liked it good one for families but it's got a little bit going on there that you could play it with a a bunch of adults too so this one i'm going to call b tier b tier for strand hunter number 39 is bandu also known as bowzak and this is also from zoc verlag games very similar to junk art this one um although i i i've got more nostalgia for bandu i played bandu for a long time before i ever got junk art and so then when i played junk art i was a little bit oh it's very similar to bandu and i love bandu and so i've never quite got on board with the whole junk art thing i still would probably gravitate towards bandu bandu is probably cheaper to get hold of as well and it's just got fantastic chunky wooden pieces everything i said about junkar also applies to bandu um it hasn't got quite as many much variety
in there as jungkook's doesn't have all those different rule sets but nonetheless bandu i'm calling i'm calling it nest here i absolutely love bandu i absolutely love it it's one of my favorites right number 40 another str this is ticket to ride but it's the anniversary editions ticket to ride alone is very attractive but it wouldn't make a game a list about table presents but those anniversary editions the 10th anniversary edition and then the 15th anniversary for europe just have amazing plastic trains in them which are painted and molded in lovely ways and they've got those tins and the whole thing just looks stunning it's bigger and brighter it just looks amazing and it's a fantastic game s tier game ticket to ride number 41 tiny towns from aeg this is another one where they've tried to create these this little cityscape okay or a town in this case tiny town and it works okay you've got these different buildings and so you you lay them out and you create something that looks quite nice the problem is it is a bit small it's not as impressive visually as something like medina um but the gameplay is really good it's essentially it's similar to a polyamino game really you're trying to create a sort of tetra shaped pattern of different coloured pieces in order to then build buildings uh that represent those pieces and so your your sort of town grows throughout the game uh really satisfying game tiny towns i really like it um beat here beat here for tiny towns number 42 historio this is a game from bruno katala and somebody else i can't remember the other designer's name
it's on the list because it's got this cardboard theater that sits at the center of it and you've got this rotating piece which indicates whether you're creating a comedy play or a tragedy play and then you've got really nice plastic pieces in there as well and lovely artwork now the game isn't as good as the way it all looks okay it's a simultaneous uh action selection game it's all right okay it's it's okay it's quite is it's fun okay i i enjoyed it i think i even put it on my top ten of the year the year that it came out but it didn't have much staying power and it didn't stay in my collection so i'm going to call this one a seed here for historio but it is beautiful number 43 is cathedral this is an older game from mattel it's essentially a very simple polyamino game it's an abstract game where you're trying to fill out the grid and block off the other player um from being able to place their pieces so you want to get more of your pieces on the board than they're able to get on the board similar to something like blockus really very similar but it's got these amazing sculpted um plastic pieces that means that it really does feel like you're creating this city full of these buildings as you're as you're playing the game i would call this one 80 okay a tier for cathedral next up on the list where are we 44 planet okay planet is another blue orange game this one with a um i don't know what you'd call this shape it's a three-dimensional geometric shape that you can rotate and click pieces onto the sides of it of different different types of terrain so you're creating a globe a planet um and you're trying to fulfill
objectives that are laid out on the table i was really looking forward to this because it looked so beautiful but actually i found it very simplistic and a little bit boring again i know it's a really popular game and there was nothing wrong with it at all i would recommend it if you're looking for something really really light and simple but it didn't hold my attention i didn't hang on to this game for very long so i'm calling this one a c tier okay i've got nothing against it but i've got nothing hugely positive to say about it either number 45 mexica it's one of the games in the trilogy of mask games so tikal cusco and mexico and mexico is my least favorite of them but it's still stunning with those resin pieces this is quite a mean area control game i've seen quite a lot of those on this list haven't we i'm calling this one um b b tier b tier game mexica number 46 bucket king 3d so bucket king 3d is a trick taking game but a very simple very chaotic one and you've got these plastic buckets uh sort of in a pyramid that sit in front of you and when you play certain cards you get to take buckets away from your opponent's pyramid and that of course might mean that the buckets on the higher levels also come off as well um and so it's a real take that game very chaotic very chance driven but it's got this amazing um i love this the jolly thinkers sort of graphic style of these pigs and dogs and lions and polar bears all all sort of battling each other um yeah really silly chaotic fun right up
my street this sort of game uh so i'm gonna call this one well it's not great i can't call it a great game let's go b tier b tier for bucket king 3d okay number 47 new york zoo so this is a uber rosenberg polyamino game and when you lay the polyaminos you might get to place animals on them little animal wooden pieces animal meeples um and so they're gonna be flamingos and penguins and foxes and i think kangaroos and and it just looks gorgeous it's just lovely the way that these pieces look as a game i would rather play baron park i'd rather play patchwork i'd rather play cottage garden um i'd rather play isle of cats you know so it is not my favorite polyamino game i found the rules a little bit convoluted a few too many exceptions and things like that and i don't like the race ending um that's my own personal taste i don't like games that end in a race like that um strategic games i've talked about this in previous videos so new york zoo didn't quite do it for me but again i can't say anything too bad about it it's a decent game i'm calling this one c tier okay c tier for new york zoo number 48 pika mouse this is a children's game from gamik uh where the box is sort of a house and then you've got this little light that you put in the top of the box and you click it on and it just stays on for 30 seconds and it goes out and during that 30 seconds you're going to be looking through the windows of the box and trying to see the pieces inside and remember where they are because when the light goes out you're going to have to say which piece was in which room um it's it's not a
game for adults to play together you know it would get pretty boring and it would get pretty easy as well but when you're playing it with children i think it's a fantastic memory game with beautiful production um so for children i would say this was an a tier game okay for adults well i wouldn't even rank it i mean i wouldn't play it with adults but with children a tier for peek-a-mouse number 49 arcadia this is an old ravensburger game by rudiger dawn and i can't believe this hasn't had a reprint okay i keep on saying this it's such a good game with brilliant table presents polyaminos you're laying out and then you're surrounding them with these little plastic meeples and then you take control of them which gives you these seals of different colors and these seals have a value to them that is dictated by the colors showing on the top of this central castle and you can add pieces to this castle uh to change the value of the different seals throughout the game so it's got a stock holding element to it everyone's got these nice colorful player shields that sit in front of them to hide the seals that they've got it's really satisfying nice and simple and slick design but with great presence um highly recommended i'm calling this one estee and and you know the biggest most overlooked game on this list i would say number 50 ice cools this is the last one we're talking about this is from brain games it's got that fantastic thing of a box within a box so you're taking the boxes out they stack inside each other you lay them out to create your big sort of playing area and then you're flicking these penguins to flick them through the doors to get the fish which are going to
score you points but one player is playing as the hall monitor they're flicking their penguin to try and make contact with the other penguins the penguins rock back and forth you can never knock them over that's a fantastic playing piece the whole thing just looks incredible and huge and you can connect ice cool one and ice cool two together to make it even bigger it's very impressive looking the game itself is great really fun flicking game so i'm gonna call this one i think it's an eight here okay one the kinder spielers yares so it's a great game for children but i think adults can play this too it's a very skillful game actually so i really like high school let's call that one atia and so that concludes my list and i know that there are some that i've missed out that probably really ought to be on here because i haven't played them basically i haven't played cleopatra and the society of architects i haven't played rescue polar bears i think these would probably be on the list if i'd played them i've left off star wars rebellion that i know a lot of people would put on here for me i went along the lines of well that's more about the miniatures and i don't really like the i don't know there's just so much stuff and and maybe i'm being contradictory there because i did put side on there so i'll acknowledge it's a good looking game what else i haven't included games like cash and guns or rock paper wizard which certainly draw the attention of other players because people are pointing at each other and doing these hand gestures or got these these polystyrene guns but it feels to me like it's the players that are drawing uh the attention rather than the actual game itself um and so they didn't make the list either so lots of
unfair stuff on this list and i'll be back next time to doing something a little bit more serious um but i hope you enjoyed this light-hearted look at 50 games that i enjoy or don't enjoy anyway join me next time uh and please subscribe to the channel let me know what you think are great games with great table presents let me know where i'm wrong let me know where i'm right and i'll see you next time all the best