Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 100 Board games: Your Guesses for my Top 10.

Transcript 28:06

hi i'm adam porter and yesterday we finished 10 videos over the last 10 days i've been showing videos of my top 100 board games that i really really love games that emotionally connect with me and over the last couple of days a couple of people have sort of commented on the videos with their own guesses at what my final 10 games would be and i said i would feed back on those after uh i'd i'd given away my top 10. so i really enjoyed all the interaction with people i really enjoyed the comments reading the comments responding to the comments hearing about which games you like what would go in your te your your top 100 games that you hadn't heard of that maybe i'd introduced you to um i really like that idea i know it's quite an eclectic sort of top 100 a whole mix of different things partly that's because it wasn't just the hundred sort of best designed games this was the hundred games that that i feel that i'm particularly sort of connected to you know the games that have a a place in my heart really games that i've got a lot of nostalgia for i've had really good experiences with and it's been nice to be able to share some of those stories of what's happened when i've played those games over the years um but i thought we'd have a look at these these guesses and and i'll talk about what my opinions are of those games you can see some of those games are actually on the shelves behind me now so the first uh the first set of ten that uh that was listed was loki who suggested that maybe i would have the games azul or sagrada on my list i haven't played cigarada i suspect i'd probably quite like it

it's a dice drafting game so you're selecting dice from a pool putting them on your board i don't know much about it i own the game role player which i like which i believe is very similar i did purchase sigrada at one point and then it didn't get played for quite some time and i ended up trading it i think but yeah it's still on it's one of those ones where you trade it away and then you regret it and you think i'd really like to have an opportunity to play that at some time azul i have played a couple of times uh i really like michael keisling who is the designer of uh azul i really like a lot of his games he did well on my top 100 um but azul didn't particularly connect with me i really like the aesthetic of it i really like those little tiles the thickness of them the the they look very beautiful but the actual gameplay um i found it was fine you know it was okay uh but it didn't really sort of grab me it felt a bit like doing a roll and right game um but without all of the sort of convenience of it being a roll and right game that's how i felt about it it wasn't a particularly satisfying puzzle for me um but i haven't tried the other versions i haven't tried stained glass of sneetra sinatra i don't know what it's called or the summer pavilion games um you know i'd be very happy to play those games again what was next on loki's list was castles of burgundy castle burgundy is uh one that i did own a number of years ago i really liked there was one point where i was buying up a lot of stephen feld games

and i think that was probably the issue i i had uh notre dame and i had castles of burgundy and uh in the year of the dragon and and then i played trajan and um bora bora and and those games just i was just done with it at that point i i really liked luna and and also later bruges um but bora bora and trajan i just found overwhelming with the number of different mechanisms all sort of tied together in it and so i kind of just got rid of all my stephen feld's stuff and i i wish i hadn't i wish i still had castles of burgundy and notre dame particularly because they were the two that i enjoyed the most of those and i'd like to give them another go so maybe i'll pick them up again at some point the next one on loki's list was seven wonders this is another one that i owned for many years i had all the expansions and everything like that and i just found i never played it i always opted for sushi go um or or other drafting games medieval academy i used to have i used to like playing that one um and now bunny kingdom i would always play bunny kingdom over seven wonders um so for seven wonders the main thing that got in the way for me was all the iconography i could never remember what all those icons meant uh and i'd always constantly have to go back to that back page of the rulebook to see what the the icons were and then try to teach it to other people when i didn't fully get it myself um was tough and it's just because i don't play

this it wasn't a game i played frequently enough to get to grips with the icons so so that that sort of killed it for me seven wonders duel i do like uh seven wonders duel uh i don't play very often but as a two-player head-to-head game i it's one that i can appreciate although it has the same issue with the icons as uh seven wonders um century spice road that was on the list i didn't get on with century spice road when i tried that um i wasn't um i was surprised that i didn't particularly enjoy splendor when that one came out uh because everyone was raving about splendor but i found it a little bit dry uh i didn't find it was something that particularly particularly connected with me and century spice throat felt the same fairly procedural really um that said i think what happened when i played century spice road was that we had a particularly unfortunate sort of card draw i think the cards that came out maybe the deck hadn't been properly shuffled it was a brand new copy of the game and and as a result we had a weird game where things just weren't really functioning properly and it was a bit drawn out and and dull so i'd really like to give it another go i particularly love the artwork on the golem edition i think that looks great next on the list then was orleans yeah orleans are really liked that was uh that's a fairly substantial um euro game with a bag building element uh like a much more strategic version of quacks of cuddling berg or something

like that where you're putting tokens into the bag and then drawing the back out buying better tokens i enjoyed that one uh it it didn't hugely connect with me i think the the thematic side of it didn't really make that much sense what was going on so you had to really really enjoy the puzzle and i quite enjoyed the puzzle but not enough to to spend the money on getting the uh the the the the ultimate version of it that that said i would happily play aliens at any time viticulture is one that i often think about picking up viticulture i do like i have played viticulture a couple of times i mentioned on the list i really like stone my games productions generally viticulture the thing that bothers me is the kind of race aspect of it i'm not a huge fan of games which just come to a sudden end when somebody hits a certain target and everybody else just doesn't really get to finish what they were doing i find that a bit frustrating um uncertain sort of timing of the ending i like to know when the end of the game is coming but i do really like all the mechanisms in viticulture it's a really good worker placement game with some nice little twists really nice production of it the wine making really works for me as a theme uh my uh my wife is german she's from uh franconia from a village that is particularly you know all about wine making when you look up at the hills all you see is is you know grapes plants all the way up surrounding the whole the whole village so so viticulture does connect with me i think i could

really get to love that if i if i got myself a copy pandemic legacy was on loki's list i've never particularly got into pandemic i'm not a huge cooperative gamer you probably noticed that from my top 100 list there aren't and a massive number of co-operative games and the ones that are on there tend to be a little bit weirder things like uh magic maze where we're all cooperating but there's some quirky mechanism in there i think flashpoint fire rescue is the is the main sort of um true sort of co-op experience like the pandemic style experience um that that i have enjoyed but but pandemic legacy i've thought about it over time i haven't played many legacy games i've played charter stone and i've played uh my city all the way through um and i've had fun with it uh i do enjoy that sort of playing the same game over and over again with my wife and exploring the sort of story of it so i would have a look at pandemic legacy but i'm just not certain i'd enjoy it and so as a result i haven't picked it up clank which is next on loki's list is actually high on my list of things to buy i've never played clank but i'm pretty sure i'd like it deck building game like deck building games dungeon crawling sort of game yeah i really like that sort of setting going into a dungeon i like this whole idea of trying not to make noise when you're going into the dungeon but your your deck picking up these clank cards i don't know much about the game i haven't looked into it hugely uh but i keep hearing wonderful things

about it and the fact there's now a legacy version uh really makes me think yeah this might be the next one to run through the next legacy game to run through with my wife and i suspect i'd probably really enjoy it i had to look at uh the game in fact um a day or two ago but the price tag put me off i mean we're talking a sort of 90 19 90 i think was yeah 90 pounds or 89 pounds or something like that was the sort of prices i was seeing online and i thought i couldn't quite bring myself to pull the trigger but i'm sure i will at some point so clank is a serious possibility for the future as is loki's next suggestion of space space uh space base i keep hearing is a better version of machikoro i like machicoro i think it's i think it's a fun game i like that system of rolling the dice and then your cards activating based on what you've rolled uh you know i'm a big fan of dice rolling games and space base apparently is a sort of improvement more strategic version uh the last one on loki's list was chronicles of crime which i suspect i probably would like but do you know i've never played a board game with an app in it i just haven't the closest i've ever come is this that's one gamble that definitely didn't pay off better luck next time yeah that's it monopoly tropical tycoon is the closest i've come to playing a board game with an app i like a board game where i can just open up the box and everything i need is in that box i don't really want to be um to

i've just thought of an app i did try i tried the imperial assault app i tried to play um imperial assault solo with the app and i found it an absolute nightmare i just i just couldn't get on with it at all but i do like to open the box have all the pieces in there to play with uh and and just get on with it and i kind of i do use board games as an escape from screens and technology and things like that so um yeah i've got i've got to get over that really haven't i because it's more and more games that are using apps and you know it is important to keep up with this stuff if you're interested in working in the industry and i'm sure chronicles of crime is exactly the sort of game i would enjoy that deduction style of things i mean my own game zoologans is a deduction game and and games like the key which was a huge favorite of mine this year that's a that is a a deduction style game looking at crimes trying to work out who did it um so chronicles of crime probably would really really work for me but i haven't played it the next list was unfussy board games who suggested chemet i don't think i'd like chemet uh i didn't enjoy cyclades and i didn't enjoy innis which are both sort of in the same range i believe of games from matagot i do like a lot of games from matagot um but that's sort of miniatures dudes on a map fighting thing and people tell me it's not that it's a euro hybrid game i know that

um and so that's why i gave cichlids a go but it didn't really work for me and i can't even remember why but it certainly wasn't like a bad group a lot of games i played them and i think well i didn't enjoy that but that's because i think i was playing with the wrong people no i was playing cyclades with people i really like and i still didn't have a good time with it so um my own personal taste but i don't think chem it's for me but i haven't tried it so who knows maybe maybe it's great time's up yes i really like that um that is a really funny party game um i i'm gonna say and this again it feels like a huge uh contradiction but it feels like it's something other than a board game because i guess it's because it's something that i would have played in the past in as an unpublished game we used to call it the hat game write names put them into the hat draw them out you'd have to you know well basically you'd play time's up but it wasn't a published sort of game and so as a result if i was going for a game night i doubt i would play time's up whereas if i was just you know hanging out with a bunch of friends over the christmas period or something and we thought right well let's just play i might play it you know if we didn't have a game around so time's up is feels slightly outside of the board game world for me even though i do have the the published version of it i like it i like time's up ganshon clever was next on unfussy board games list so this is a dice game roll them right from wolfgang vorsh it's a really good one so you're rolling

the dice you you're keeping one dice and then you have to get rid of all the other dice that are lower than the dice you've picked so you're wanting to pick the lowest dice to give yourself more options later but the lower dice don't score you as much it's a really clever system i must admit i miss the the nice sort of aesthetic of welcome 2 and cartographers in this one even though the gameplay is just as good in uh ganshawn clever but the fact that it's abstract doesn't have any sort of theme it looks like a spreadsheet it just turns me off a little bit i do prefer just to have that vague sense of of setting you know an atmosphere around it that ganshawn clever misses but i do really like the gameplay um i'm looking forward to the pinball game from jeff inglestein i can't remember what that's called uh but yes it hasn't come out in the uk yet but i like that idea of filling out a sheet but it being a pinball um a pinball table and there's another one as well i'm looking forward to called floor plan where you're filling out a grid and you're placing different rooms in different locations um to to build a sort of as an architect to kind of build a home i like that idea as well so i'm looking forward to that one coming up but again not out in the uk yet uh next on the list then from unfussy board games was uh village so village is a game that i do have uh village is a game that i really

really enjoyed when i first had it then i got bored of it felt there wasn't much variety in that box uh so i traded it away then later on i thought oh my wife would really like village i really wish i could play village with my wife because she hadn't played it and so i got myself another copy of village played it with my wife she didn't particularly like it but i really enjoyed it so as a result it's had a bit of a checkered history with me village it's an interesting action selection game uh i suspect it would be improved with the expansions village port and village inn i've never played it with those but i've heard good things about them um but because it hasn't really kind of well i'm not sure i want to invest in it in the game so i haven't bought those expansions but maybe i'll try a friend's copy at some point kingsberg is a really good game really nice game where you're rolling dice and then you're choosing do you want to spread those dice over multiple different action spaces but but taking low value actions or do you combine the dice and take fewer actions but really powerful ones the actions give you resources which you can spend to buy these really nice um sort of special abilities uh it's a lovely the production i have is the fantasy flight edition i know there was a later edition uh but my audition i really like the way it looks i've always felt the game takes a little bit longer than it should um but i should try again i haven't played it a huge number of times and i did really enjoy it so kingsberg is yeah it's it's a really good one it it doesn't hit my top 100 but i really

really like it uh skull skull should like skull shouldn't i i feel like skull is one of those ones where i have um i've played it with the wrong group yeah so i've sat down to play it and with probably with a group of people who didn't really know each other and so as a result on a games day you know where where you're playing with strangers and and so this hasn't been that banter and um uh and the bluffing and lying hasn't been as fun as it should be um the production doesn't do anything for me the the um the table mats the the pub bar mats you know that stuff doesn't really work for me i'd rather you know i really like the production of cockroach poker for example and i suspect it's a similar sort of experience um but i should give this one another chance it really is right up my alley um so i'm i'm sure if i you know got together the right group in the right mood and played this game i'm sure i would love skull citadels i really didn't like this is brutal duty's most sort of popular game played this very early when i first got into the hobby played it a number of times it was one of the first games that was really popular at the time but i didn't really like um it was felt mean it felt i i had games of it where i thought i was doing really really well and then suddenly somebody would play a card that would just destroy all my plans and you know the crushing disappointment of you know i thought i was doing well here and then someone's just ruined it for me i found it was a game where i i could

see the ending coming and i'm quite looking forward to the end because i wasn't particularly enjoying it and then someone would play a card that would lengthen the game by 20 minutes and i hate that in a game where i can see the end coming and then and then somebody just goes right there we go and there we go we've got another 20 minutes now before the game ends i can't remember why that happened but that's my lasting memory of citadels it is a game that i would actively turn down playing at this point although i know a load of people really really like it so i must be in the wrong uh no thanks i do really like no thanks um no thanks i ought to play more than i do uh i've got a really nice german version of it called sherna scheisse with with this fantastic artwork of all sorts of different sort of weird unfortunate incidents going on um it's a it's a nice sort of pushy luck style game again isn't it and i i do like push your luck um so yeah i i i think this is one that uh that very well should have been close to the top hundred shouldn't it i just haven't played it that much really no thanks uh six nympht six nympht you'd think was right up my alley as well wouldn't you um i've always felt six nymphs is fun but always i would always be happy to play it um i have to i have a version of it called xnimpt i think i used to have six nymph and i used to have another one was it called eleven nympt or something like that you could play with more players i think and it was a variant of it i don't know what happened to that copy the current copy i have is x nympt um

which has a slightly altered rule set and you play it with a lower play account um i believe it's a little bit more strategic than six nymph but still the the decisions you make in the game are very very slight they have minimal impact on whether you succeed or not they have a little bit of impact but not a huge amount and so that's where it separates from a trick taking game to me with a trick taking game i feel like i can play intelligently i can do stuff that's really clever and and feel that i've yeah i've played that well um i don't really get that with six nymph although it's a fun time just throwing the cards down so it wouldn't come anywhere near my top 100 but i do like that whole series of six nymph x nymphs whatever that other one was 11 nymph or whatever it was um ra was next on unfussy board games uh suggested uh games that would be on my top 10. uh i haven't played ra i've played priests of ra which is basically the same game and that's the version i've got i think priest of ra is probably a more um friendlier version i think a little bit more cut a little bit less cut throat perhaps more family friendly i really like the way the game looks i've only played it i believe um once i think a long time ago and i really really liked it but it was a long time ago and so it couldn't make my top 100 because why haven't i played it again um that said i think it's got really really clever mechanisms it's got some you know i suppose it reminds me a

little bit of ryan clitzy's high society it's all the priest of royal it's also by ryan kanitzia that idea of being able to bid but you've got only very limited bidding tokens and you can't make change so if you give one of your big bidding tokens you're losing that token although in prison then getting another token back so so that little pool of of available tokens to bid with is is um changing from from round to round uh and and you're collecting up different sets of tiles to score in a variety of different ways um similar to something like sushi go or emote or something like that um i think i i ought to get this to the table again soon i suspect i could really really grow to love priest or or ra if i had a copy of that version okay right the other person who predicted my top 10 was bruce knight he said that evolution would be on there he's been watching my previous videos uh because i talk about evolution all the time i always say that's my favorite game so yes obviously that was going to be on there abyss he suggested yes indeed abyss is my second favorite game and i've mentioned that a few times as well so bruce has been watching closely uh he said maybe there'd be one more game from the mask trilogy because cuzco and tikal had already been on the list mexico didn't make my top 100. i do really like mexico certainly if we'd gone to 150 maybe 120 130 it would be in there okay mexico i feel is a very different game to cusco and tcal it just feels different in some ways it feels meaner you're

you're jumping in there taking slots someone else thinks they're doing well and you just jump in there with your pieces and steal it away from them all block them off so that they can't achieve what they were going for so it's a little bit more cutthroat uh but again a beautiful beautiful production by super meeple in the most recent version um but i've always felt it's the weakest of the three for me but i i do like it it uses similar mechanisms action points and all of that stuff so again not a game to play with people who are prone to sitting and taking ages to take their turn uh right next game on bruce's list again he says skull yeah okay i've already said i really need to explore that more then he says perudo or liar's dice yes i really like perudo um again perudo is a game that i suppose i played before i got into the hobby board games the modern board games um it was never a sort of huge favorite but i did i did play it and as a result i've always felt like it was a game that from before like a game a mass-market style game and i don't have any i'm not i'm not the snob i once was about the mass market i suppose i used to turn my nose up at that i don't really anymore and so i ought to give it another chance but a bit like time's up it just feels like something a little bit outside of the hobby it's never a game that i would particularly reach for even though i think it's really really good and really really clever so yeah great game but not one that emotionally connects with me perudo anomia is a fantastic game anomier is a

speed reaction game where you're playing turning over a card someone else is turning over a card and if the two the symbols on the two cards match you have a race to to call something out and you've got to say something which is written on the other person's card so it might say types of ice cream or it might say um i don't know supermarket or something like that and you've got to call out like a supermarket so tesco or whatever or you've got to call out a type of ice cream you know before the other player or sports team or a celebrity or whatever it says on the card and then in order to win the card and of course you're trying to do it so quickly that you're falling over yourself you can't get the words out hence the name anomia it's uh it's hilarious it's really really funny really really good and i really like those sort of speed games and nomia was a big inspiration for big bazaar along with other similar games like jungle speed and snorter uh and then a little bit of things like ghost splits and stuff like that thrown in there as well uh the main thing i found with anomia is that i just think it's ugly i just the the the everything's the the text the the symbols it there's it's just got the absolute minimum on those cards and so i wanted big bazaar to be something quite beautiful lots of images no text i didn't want anyone to have to read or anything like that um and i wanted a lot of variety in the different ways that you could play so lots of very variants that sort of creep in there and the game keeps changing as you play it

next on the list then for bruce knight was pick a pig i love pekka pig pika pig would definitely be uh close to my top 100. pick a pig pick a dog pick a polar bear pick a seal doesn't matter which one you play or you could buy two of them and mix them together and play a larger game in pick a pig you have a grid full of cards you know laid out on the table and then you've got one card in your hand and you have to take cards from that grid but they must have just one subtle change from your card so the images are all very similar so it might be that you've got a big pig and so the next one you want to take is exactly the same pig but smaller and then the item that they're holding changes and so you have to take something where he's still small but he's taken one thing and then he maybe gets bigger and then maybe he changes color but you can only have one difference if the card that you take has two differences you've gone wrong and you're getting nothing but you're doing this at speed racing against the other players and then at the end you have to demonstrate that you've got it correct and you haven't made any mistakes and then you're going to score the points it's very frantic but very simple i love jolly thinkers whole range of those that whole range of games jolly pets range um with um fruit spy and bucket king 3d and anima crazy and bye bye black sheep you know the these games none of those would make the top 100 but i do really like them but pick a pig is is certainly a pick a dog certainly the best of the bunch um and yeah yeah just really fun speed games so anyway that's my thought on your predictions there weren't many

that you guys got correct so uh maybe i'm not that predictable um but uh but i i really appreciate you joining in and watching and commenting um i think it'll probably be a little while before i make too many more videos because that took me a load of time and i do have another job as well as my game you know game designing is my my sideline but i i'm you know i'm a dentist hard time to be doing dentistry in the pandemic um and i've got a lot of other stuff going on um so uh so i don't know when it will be that i'll make a video again but please keep watching there's loads of other videos of course on my channel to go back and watch uh on adam's board game wales follow me on twitter at board game wales on board game geek adam78 so thanks very much for watching all the best

Progress saved